Neil Gaiman: Why defend freedom of icky speech? Sleazy manga vs everything else
Posted By admin on June 24, 2011
So, this just came up in Neil Gaiman’s facebook. Apparently an American got arrested in Canada for having creepy manga. Gaiman, a favorite author of mine, cites an old blog post of his in defense of the American…this one’s tough, and I suspect a lot of research will be needed to form a defendable position, and I have no research. And I am lazy. Uh oh, is this how right wing arguments form? Zing!
Still, emotionally, I think stuff like that should be controlled, and I just don’t think comparing something by Alan Moore with lolicon is fair. Like Gaiman, I’ve never actually seen lolicon, but I have heard of its reputation, and I have come across some very misogynistic non-lolicon works (in fact, I eventually realized most works by male manga authors always seem to have this weird sleazy angle to it [random panty shots that have nothing to do with the plot!?!]). Tenjo Tenge is one. It’s an action-packed, martial arts manga on the surface (with the usual male mangaka perv angle, or so I thought), but every x chapters, there’s a rape, and eventually, in the words of SomethingAwful.com, it’s not just mild rape, it’s insane rape. Very reminiscent of warcrimes committed during ww2. The first “normal” rape I could rationalize. “Hmm, ok, maybe he’s setting up some kind of emotional trauma to explore its ramifications. Now there is a vendetta between both sides.” But no, the victim never really thinks about it, ever, whether alone or with others. Like it was no big deal. The other characters treat it like that, too. “Oh, just rape. It’s coo. We’ll go punch him in the face.” Then the rapes start getting S&M-y, and then eventually execution by mutilation starts happening. Yeah, I stopped reading. It kind of blew my mind that it was picked up for conversion into an anime series, as well as for import to the US (with a lot of it redacted). But I searched the author’s name, followed the rabbit down the hole, and saw some things I wish I had never seen. So yeah, comparing Alan Moore with that? I don’t think that’s fair at all. For the record, I haven’t read the cited Moore work, Lost Girls, but I have read Watchmen, and I’ve seen V for Vendetta, does that count? I figure those works alone are so far above a mindless martial arts manga with rampant rape.
Anyway, I must go soon. Cue something about drawing the line on freedom of speech, and how mobile it is through time and space (what country you happen to be in), and something about how the blogger in Taiwan got arrested for a negative restaurant review, and another example from Europe, how insane the rape scene is in the King James bible, blah blah blah. You guys fill in the blanks. You’re smart. Write this shit for me.
Update: I suppose if I compare this to very liberal drug laws, which seem to be quite effective, perhaps it should be open season for anything when it comes to fiction, too. For those unfamiliar, various countries have tried letting people do whatever the hell they want when it comes to drugs, which has actually lowered crime due to the muted effect on the black market. Still, to succeed those countries also needed to create a support network to get people off drugs. I’m not sure what the equivalent would be for insane fiction.



